The power of ice cream: why surprise wins in business

Toby Martin

The best bit of the steak wasn’t the steak.

Don’t get me wrong, Flat Iron serves up a mean piece of meat. But what really stuck in my mind from a recent visit with my wife wasn’t what was on the plate. It was what came after the bill.

Two silver tokens, placed on the table with a little flourish. “These are for free ice creams,” the server said. “You can use them whenever you like.”

Reader, we did not wait. We practically sprinted. Despite the fact it was freezing. Despite the fact it was raining. Despite the fact we were full of steak. We stood outside in the drizzle, grinning like idiots, eating ice cream. And then, inevitably: we shared it on social media. We told friends. We remembered it.

And that’s the magic of moments like this: small, unexpected gestures that create delight, tell a story, and make people want to talk about your business.

This wasn’t about a discount or a loyalty card or a big bold offer. This was about a moment. A memory. A completely unnecessary act of generosity that earned our loyalty and our storytelling for free.

And they’re not alone.

Capital One once had a customer casually mention, during a routine call, that she was mid-way through a horrendous kitchen renovation. Plaster dust everywhere. Nowhere to put her coffee. Just a throwaway comment. But two weeks later, a parcel arrived at her door: a memory foam kitchen mat, and a handwritten note from the rep she’d spoken to. It had no bearing on her credit limit, her APR, or her customer status. But it had everything to do with trust. A pure, unexpected deposit into what Stephen Covey would call her “Emotional Bank Account.”

It’s a concept worth borrowing. Covey says every relationship is like an emotional bank account. Each positive interaction makes a deposit. Each negative one is a withdrawal. The higher the balance, the higher the trust. Simple—and powerful.

Let’s deposit another story.

Omnisend—a B2B email marketing platform of all things—who’ve somehow mastered the art of being brilliantly, cheekily human. Brand Manager Pija Ona Indriūnaitė started sending T-shirts to customers that didn’t respond to account managers. But not just any T-shirts. One read: “I ghosted Omnisend, so they sent me this awesome T-shirt.” Another: “Another meeting that could have been an email.” It’s funny. It’s bold. It’s memorable.

And then there’s Chewy, the online pet retailer. When customers notify them that a beloved pet has passed away, Chewy often sends flowers, a pet portrait and a condolence card. No automated emails. No sneaky sales pitch for a new puppy bed. Just a human response to another human being. In a world of “click to cancel,” it stands out like a heartbeat in the silence. And crucially, it doesn’t feel like a marketing ploy. It feels like someone, somewhere, gave a damn.

Octopus Energy do too. After a simple call to update account details, a customer casually mentioned they were recovering from surgery. The rep could have said “Hope you feel better soon” and carried on. Instead, a few days later, a bouquet of flowers arrived at the customer’s home. No fanfare. Just kindness. A deposit made.

So what can estate agents learn from this?

Our industry is built on relationships. But too often, we stop nurturing them the second the keys change hands.

The best agencies I know go further. Location Location in Stoke Newington put a huge ribbon on the front door on moving day. It’s simple, it’s joyful—and it’s been shared thousands of times.

But you don’t have to stop there.

What if, instead of the standard home move box filled with wet wipes and oatcakes, you used AI to create a Pixar-style image of their new home being lifted into the sky by helium balloons in the style of Up, and framed it as a gift?

What if you logged a throwaway comment the client made about their son’s graduation date in your CRM and sent a handwritten congratulations card months after the move?

What if you stopped expecting to be offered tea and coffee upon arrival at the market appraisal, and called ahead to offer one from the local coffee shop?

What if you looked for tiny ways to say: “We care.”

Because when you do that, you’re not just closing deals—you’re making deposits. You’re creating moments worth talking about.

And in a business that thrives on referrals, reputation, and retention—that’s the kind of marketing money can’t buy.

 

Toby Martin is an experienced estate agent consultant specialising in residential lettings, marketing, and training 

 

What is currently happening in the UK property market?

 

x

Email the story to a friend!



4 Comments

  1. SimonLBradbury

    You have absolutely nailed it Toby… spot on! The amazing thing is, these ideas don’t actually cost much money – just a little thought.

    Report
    1. Robert_May

      How spooky is this…

      Before most people were even awake this morning, I was designing an artisan ice cream — a freezer treat for guests at the chalet we holiday let in Croyde.

      Later in the day, I read Toby Martin’s brilliant post on Property Industry Eye about the power of small, unexpected gestures — the kind that create memories, build loyalty, and shape reputation. A scoop of free ice cream in the rain. A condolence card from a pet company. Genuine human touches that land where and when it matters.

      That’s exactly what this is. A surprise in the freezer. Not mass-produced. Not for sale. Just something quietly memorable for the families who stay. Especially the children — they remember.

      Simon Bradbury, you saw the place when we’d just started the rebuild. It’s nearly finished now — and we’ve still got a few summer vacancies. The freezer’s not exactly stocked — just some ice cubes… and whatever I’ve engineered that week. The latest? A blackcurrant and amaretto ripple that might be my best yet.

      But this isn’t really about food. Or even hospitality. It’s about creating a moment. A gesture. Something guests take home and talk about.

      Even if it comes with a triple red health warning and 300 calories a scoop… it’s still magic.

      Report
      1. SimonLBradbury

        Spot on Robert May – I certainly remember your amazing place in Croyde where you very kindly supplied me with tea and biscuits – a very welcome surprise!

        Report
  2. Whaley

    What are you talking about I AM the small unexpected gift that delights in our service!!

    Report
X

You must be logged in to report this comment!

Comments are closed.

Thank you for signing up to our newsletter, we have sent you an email asking you to confirm your subscription. Additionally if you would like to create a free EYE account which allows you to comment on news stories and manage your email subscriptions please enter a password below.