Rejected – Government won’t debate petition equating rental payments with mortgage affordability

The Government has rebuffed calls to make lenders consider rental payments as enough proof that a home buyer can afford a mortgage.

A petition on the website in March reached more than the 100,000 signatures needed to be considered by MPs for debate.

The petition, attributed to Jamie Jack Pogson, said: “Since living on my own I have paid £70,000+ in rent on time yet still struggle to get a mortgage.

“Unless you’re getting handouts, wealthy or in receipt of inheritance, it’s almost impossible. I want paying rent on time to be recognised as evidence that mortgage repayments can be met.”

But rather than set a debate to consider the petition, the Government instead issued a statement that said: “Rental payments is not sufficient in itself to demonstrate affordability over the lifetime of the loan.”

The response from the Treasury pointed out that affordability is measured by a range of factors such as income and other expenditure.

It also said home ownership brings a number of additional expenses that may not be incurred when renting, including maintenance costs and buildings insurance.

The Government concluded: “Beyond the Financial Conduct Authority’s requirements, decisions around the availability of individual mortgage loans remain commercial decisions for lenders, and the Government does not seek to intervene in these.

“While one lender may be unable to offer a mortgage, being denied a mortgage from one provider does not preclude a customer from being offered credit elsewhere.

“There are a wide variety of mortgage products available in the UK and prospective borrowers may benefit from shopping around.”


Email the story to a friend

One Comment

  1. AgentV

    There is a continuing disparity between property prices and what people can borrow to buy. The disparity is increasing with rising prices fuelled by scarcity of stock. Government measures have contributed to limiting supply.

    if more and more people are going to be driven into ‘lifetime renters’ who is going to pay all the rents when they retire?


You must be logged in to report this comment!

Leave a reply

Thank you for signing up to our newsletter, we have sent you an email asking you to confirm your subscription. Additionally if you would like to create a free EYE account which allows you to comment on news stories and manage your email subscriptions please enter a password below.