
Charlie Lamdin’s BestAgent has hit back at mounting criticism over its property listings and viewing charges, issuing a lengthy defence after a bruising week for the platform.
The statement follows the resignation of Yopa chief executive Verona Frankish from its advisory board less than 24 hours earlier, amid concerns over the company’s direction and management.
BestAgent has sought to clarify its position on viewing charges, property listings and anonymous comments.
It insists buyer and tenant enquiries remain free, despite an agent receiving an £8 plus VAT payment request during a test of its viewing system.
However, the company has confirmed plans to introduce charges for online enquiries in future.
The statement also reinforces BestAgent’s position on displaying property information without agents supplying marketing material.
BestAgent explains disputed £8 viewing charge
The controversy erupted on Tuesday after Andrew Muskett, manager of David Burr’s Woolpit office in Suffolk, challenged BestAgent over its business practices.
Muskett tested the platform’s viewing system and received emails requesting £8 plus VAT to access an enquiry and confirm an appointment.
He declined to pay. The viewing subsequently failed to proceed.
Lamdin insisted on Wednesday that buyer and tenant leads were free. However, he did not directly explain the payment request.
BestAgent has now provided further clarification.
The company stated: “But for now and until further notice, all buyer and tenant leads remain completely free of charge.”
It added: “Any agent who has seen a buyer lead email with a price on it is most likely either testing the system themselves or receiving a test enquiry from BestAgent itself.”
BestAgent maintains that it has always passed genuine enquiries to agents without charge.
“To our knowledge, no agent has ever paid us anything for an applicant enquiry. If it has happened, it was in error and we would gladly provide a refund.”
However, the statement does not specifically explain why Muskett received the £8 plus VAT request or why his test viewing failed.
BestAgent confirms future lead charges
Despite insisting that enquiries remain free, BestAgent confirmed plans to introduce a pay-per-lead model.
The proposed charges would depend on the property’s advertised price.
BestAgent argues that this approach would offer agents greater control over marketing costs than traditional portal subscriptions.
Telephone enquiries made directly to agents through property listings will remain free.
The company also plans to introduce refunds for leads involving applicants who provide misleading information.
It says charges will only begin once agents are satisfied with the quality and reliability of its enquiry system.
Property listings dispute continues
BestAgent also defended its approach to displaying property information, regardless of whether agents supply marketing material.
The company said: “Whether or not an agent supplies marketing materials, we will be listing all publicly available data from all public sources on every listing where possible.”
The statement follows Muskett’s complaint about the reproduction of David Burr’s photographs, floorplans and property descriptions.
He says neither the agency nor its vendors authorised their use.
On Wednesday, Lamdin argued that basic property information was not protected by copyright.
He also warned agents demanding the removal of listings that they might have to justify their actions to vendors.
BestAgent maintains that factual property information can remain visible even when agents request the removal of marketing content.
However, its latest statement does not explain what permissions support the initial reproduction of agents’ photographs, floorplans and descriptions.
It also fails to address Muskett’s account of an alleged £500 lead-credit offer linked to withdrawing a removal request.
Questions about potential reactivation fees also remain unanswered.
Anonymous property comments defended
BestAgent has also defended its controversial public commenting feature.
Muskett previously raised concerns about anonymous comments appearing alongside David Burr’s property listings.
He questioned whether contributors had viewed the homes and how agents could challenge potentially inaccurate remarks.
BestAgent argues that public comments will encourage greater transparency and improve listing accuracy.
The company says agents can respond to comments or suspend those they consider unduly harmful.
Verified sellers will also be able to receive notifications and respond publicly or anonymously.
However, the statement does not directly address Muskett’s concerns about having to activate BestAgent’s BackOffice system to moderate comments.
Frankish resignation adds to pressure
The statement follows another setback for Lamdin after Verona Frankish resigned from BestAgent’s advisory board last night.
The Yopa chief executive said recent developments had convinced her that management’s approach no longer aligned with her professional values.
She stated: “Innovation and disruption should never come at the expense of integrity, collaboration or professional standards.”
Frankish had joined the advisory board to support efforts to improve transparency and reduce transaction delays.
Her departure follows several days of criticism over BestAgent’s handling of property listings and viewing enquiries.
BestAgent’s latest statement does not directly address her resignation.
BestAgent admits platform remains under construction
BestAgent acknowledged that its housing marketplace remains a work in progress.
The company says its system currently includes more than 10,000 estate agency firms and 17,000 branches.
It also confirmed that updates and new features are appearing almost daily.
“Save for any signed agreements, everything about it is subject to change without notice,” the statement said.
BestAgent maintains that its objective is to shorten transaction times, reduce fall-throughs and improve transparency.
However, several questions remain following a turbulent week.
These include the use of agents’ marketing material, the operation of its viewing system and the conditions attached to managing listings.
BestAgent has also advised agents wishing to submit formal notices to contact legal@bestagent.co.uk, stressing that the address is reserved exclusively for formal notices
The latest statement clarifies BestAgent’s intended charging model. But whether it will satisfy agents who have challenged its practices remains to be seen.


Comments (8)
It would be interesting to know how much the management’s approach changed to cause Verona Frankish to resign?
I don’t want to be seen as promoting so they’ll remain nameless, but we were contacted a few months ago by a platform that asked for 10% of our fee when we sold a property from someone they introduced to us. That’s it, They send us free valuation leads and viewing requests. It’s only a trickle but there’s no subscription fees, no per-lead fees. It either works out and everyone wins or it doesn’t and nobody loses. I really hope everyone gets behind it and we can all eventually move away from the dominant high subscription fee model or this pay-per lead model in this case.
Any agent who has seen a buyer lead email with a price on it is most likely either testing the system themselves or receiving a test enquiry from BestAgent itself.” watch his nose grow like Pinocchio’sssssssssssssssssssssssssss
Honestly Charlie – stop digging. Packing your board with worthy names doesn’t fool anyone, ask Elizabeth Holmes. You may be thinking all this is great PR, it’s not and what you need ISN’T B2B advertising, all of which has been unremittingly negative, if you’d tried to persuade Agents that you’ve got the wherewithal to heavily promote B2C – the only thing which will bring eyes on the site – you might have taken them with you. But this hasn’t happened and instead we get obfuscation?
Another lengthy statement from Charlie explaining what BestAgent wants to achieve, but still very little in the way of answers to the questions agents have been asking.
Who gave BestAgent permission to use our photographs, floorplans and descriptions? Where exactly is the data coming from? Why was I asked for £8 plus VAT to access a viewing enquiry if it was supposedly only a test? And how did BestAgent manage to give one of our properties a swimming pool it doesn’t have?
Then there’s the £500 credit offer to agents who withdrew their removal requests, and the anonymous comments appearing alongside our clients’ homes.
These aren’t difficult questions, yet they remain unanswered.
Charlie talks about agents and consumers working together, but here’s the problem. We were never asked if we wanted to be involved in the first place.
Our marketing material was taken and published without our permission, and when we objected, we were effectively told that BestAgent would decide what stayed and what went.
I’ve spoken to a lot of agents over the past week, and I can assure Charlie that the frustration and anger are very real. These are people running businesses, employing staff and looking after clients who have trusted them with the sale of their homes.
Charlie says BestAgent is being built in a live environment and everything is subject to change. That’s his choice, but it doesn’t mean other businesses should have to accept being part of the experiment without their agreement.
You can’t claim to be working with an industry while ignoring the concerns of the people you’re supposedly working with.
It’s time for some straight answers rather than another explanation of the vision.
The arrogance and utter unwillingness to read the room is staggering, isn’t it?
“Any agent who has seen a buyer lead email with a price on it is most likely either testing the system themselves or receiving a test enquiry from BestAgent itself.”… How does a system not clever enough to even copy basic sales features correctly discern a test viewing (using a different email address) from a genuine leads? The answer? It doesn’t.
Enough lies now Charlie.
I tested the viewing process on the site from both the consumer and agent perspectives.
When I registered as a potential viewer, there was no clear explanation that my details would be sold to the agent as a lead. Instead, I simply received a message saying that the agent was being asked to confirm my viewing.
However, from the agent’s side, I received an email asking me to pay £4.70 to “buy the lead”, which would give me access to the potential viewer’s full name, email address, mobile number and full address.
My concern is that this isn’t transparent to the consumer. They are left believing they have requested a viewing and are waiting for the agent to respond, when in reality the agent is being asked to pay to access their details before they can even make contact.
This potentially reflects quite badly on the agent, as it creates the impression that we are ignoring viewing requests or failing to respond, when that isn’t actually the case.
I have screenshots of the consumer journey and copies of the emails received, which demonstrate exactly how the process works.
I did the same. It’s a terrible journey. The proposed viewing time slipped past with no communication from Bestagent. Was simply left to think the agent wasn’t interested.
The transparency Charlie Lamdin crows about couldn’t be further from the process.