
Charlie Lamdin has hit back at estate agents demanding the removal of their property listings from BestAgent, warning that they may have to justify their actions to vendors.
The BestAgent founder has issued a defiant statement amid growing criticism of the platform’s use of agents’ property listings, marketing material and viewing arrangements.
Lamdin insists that basic property information will remain on BestAgent, even when agents demand the removal of photographs, floorplans and descriptions.
He also claims fewer than 1% of agents listed on the platform have complained.
His intervention follows an EYE report highlighting concerns raised by Andrew Muskett, manager at David Burr’s Woolpit office in Suffolk.
Muskett questioned BestAgent’s use of his agency’s marketing material, its handling of viewing enquiries and the publication of anonymous comments about properties.
The article subsequently prompted further debate among agents in EYE’s comments section. Some readers also drew comparisons with Houser, a property website that previously attracted controversy over its approach to reproducing estate agents’ listings.
The comparisons have revived questions about who controls property marketing material once it appears online, and whether agents should have a say in how third-party platforms use it.
‘Agents who demand listings be taken down are missing the point’
Lamdin makes clear that BestAgent has no intention of abandoning its approach to displaying publicly available property information.
In a statement issued on 17 November, he said: “Basic property listing data is not copyright. The address, price, size, energy rating and sold history are public facts, and they stay on BestAgent, with or without the marketing content.
“Agents who demand that listings be taken down are missing this point.”
His position draws a distinction between basic property information and marketing content that may attract copyright protection.
BestAgent says agents can request the removal of photographs, floorplans and descriptions. However, the underlying property information will remain visible.
Lamdin then turns the argument back on agents seeking removal.
“Every seller pays their agent to market their home well. An agent who pulls the marketing will need to consider whether that’s in their seller’s best interests, and be ready to explain that choice to their seller.”
The comments are likely to divide agents who believe they should control where their marketing material appears and those who favour wider exposure for their listings.
BestAgent confirms AI indexing of agents’ websites
Lamdin has also explained how BestAgent obtains property listings.
“BestAgent uses AI to index residential property listings from publicly available sources, including estate agents’ own websites.”
He says the company is developing a system that will allow agents to control their listings without traditional data feeds.
BestAgent does not intend to charge agents for that facility.
However, the statement leaves questions about the permissions obtained before the platform reproduces photographs, floorplans and property descriptions.
Muskett previously challenged BestAgent over its use of David Burr’s marketing material without the agency’s consent.
The distinction between publicly available information and copyright-protected marketing content remains central to the dispute.
‘Less than 1% of agents have complained’
Despite the criticism, Lamdin argues that complaints represent only a small proportion of agents appearing on BestAgent.
“Much less than 1% of agents that we list have complained, suggesting most see the value in free extra exposure and the opportunity to talk to more sellers as an obvious way to derive more value from their listings at no cost.”
However, the absence of a complaint does not necessarily mean an agent has approved the platform’s practices.
Lamdin says BestAgent is speaking directly with agents who have raised concerns.
He also maintains that buyer and tenant leads are free.
“Buyer and tenant leads are free for agents, and no agent has ever paid for one. We list your homes, you get the buyer leads, free.”
That assertion comes amid questions about BestAgent’s viewing-enquiry arrangements.
Muskett previously raised concerns about a reported £8 plus VAT charge associated with viewing requests.
Lamdin’s latest statement does not directly explain how that arrangement operates or what happens when an agent declines to pay.
‘Good agents have nothing to fear’
Lamdin is also pressing ahead with BestAgent’s Seller’s Sense Check, which allows homeowners to compare their property’s performance with local market activity.
The system examines asking prices, nearby sales and competing properties. It also compares an instructed agent’s track record with other local agencies.
Lamdin said: “Good agents have nothing to fear from that, and a great deal to gain.”
He argues that sellers currently lack sufficient information to assess whether their agent is performing effectively.
The statement includes an example involving a five-bedroom detached property in a Suffolk village.
According to BestAgent’s analysis, the instructed agent found buyers for one-third of its detached properties that left the market during the period examined. Other local agents achieved a rate of around half.
Lamdin acknowledges the small sample and describes the comparison as indicative.
The example links to a BestAgent report for Woolpit, where David Burr operates an office.
However, the statement does not identify the agency involved in that comparison.
Questions remain over viewing fees and anonymous comments
Although Lamdin has defended BestAgent’s wider approach, several questions raised in EYE’s earlier coverage remain unanswered.
These include how the platform handles viewing enquiries when an agent declines the associated charge.
There are also outstanding questions about anonymous comments on property listings and the process for challenging their accuracy.
Muskett previously questioned an offer of £500 in lead credits to withdraw a marketing-content removal request, along with the possibility of subsequent reactivation fees.
Lamdin’s latest statement does not directly address those arrangements, despite EYE having specifically asked him to clarify the viewing charges, the £500 lead-credit offer and potential reactivation fees.
‘Transparency is overdue’
Lamdin insists BestAgent will continue developing its platform despite the objections.
He said: “Transparency is overdue in this market. BestAgent is here to bring it, no matter what happens, for the benefit of society as a whole.”
For agents, however, the dispute raises a more immediate question.
Should a third-party platform be able to display information about their clients’ properties, assess their performance and retain basic listings even after the instructed agent objects?
Lamdin believes greater transparency benefits sellers and buyers.
Some agents are questioning whether that transparency should come at the expense of control over their listings and marketing material.
The disagreement shows little sign of ending.

