Deposit diaries: Dispute after tenants chopped branch off tree without owner’s permission

Welcome to this month’s edition of The Deposit Diaries where the assistant director of dispute resolution at TDS, Sandy Bastin, discusses a recent decision by an adjudicator and sets out the reasoning behind it

In this case, the landlord claimed £225 for a missing tree branch. This was based on the estimated value the tree branch would have fetched as firewood.

The landlord said the tenants reported an issue with the tree branch when living at the property and were advised that the matter would be dealt with when the tenancy ended.

The tenants removed the branch during the tenancy and argued that it was done with the agreement of the agent, who had stated that the tree branch was dangerous and should be removed. The tenants also made the case that they offered to return the tree branch to the landlord.

The adjudicator noted the agents’ comment that ‘the tree was dangerous and should be removed’. This was relayed by the tenants to the landlord via email but the adjudicator concluded that this did not amount to permission from the landlord to remove the tree branch.

No evidence was provided to show that the tree branch was indeed dangerous. The adjudicator did accept, however, that a large tree branch was removed without permission during the tenancy. While an award was due, the adjudicator considered that only £50 was justified.

Awarding the full £225 claimed was deemed unreasonable. There was no evidence, such as a report from a contractor, to support the value of the wood claimed by the landlords. The tenants also did not appear to have been told that the landlord intended to use the branch as firewood.

Conclusion

This case highlights the importance of ensuring that unequivocal agreement in writing is obtained before any item(s) are removed from the property, including the garden. If there are any conditions attached to permission to remove items, make sure that these are documented clearly. Submit evidence, such as a contractor’s report, in support of amounts claimed, and where possible keep any losses claimed to a fair and reasonable amount, particularly where an item is removed.

The Tenancy Deposit Scheme offers both insured and custodial protection

x

Email the story to a friend

5 Comments

  1. Mark Walker

    This is just the worst.

    Landlord’s failure to act when tenant and agent have reported something dangerous.  Landlord then trying to make a massive profit out of the tenants’ deposit.  TDS awarding anything when the tenants had offered the offending item to the landlord.

    Sandy, reconsider your position.

    Report
  2. Woodentop

    I would be interested to see the outcome if a photograph was shown to confirm the branch was dangerous.

    Report
  3. Eric Walker

    This wouldn’t affect online agents. They don’t have branches. 🙂

    Report
  4. P-Daddy

    There is no hope for our fellow man. We have become pathetic in the 21st Century….and what about the poor defenseless tree…I’m going to set up a Just Giving page to help this and other limbless trees and shrubs. Might even ask Sting to write a song to highlight their plight

    Report
    1. Woodentop

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6vFWmLXl3g

       

      Report
X

You must be logged in to report this comment!

Leave a reply

Thank you for signing up to our newsletter, we have sent you an email asking you to confirm your subscription. Additionally if you would like to create a free EYE account which allows you to comment on news stories and manage your email subscriptions please enter a password below.