Agent in Australia prosecuted for advertising artificially low guide price

In a story which could resonate with some UK agents and auctioneers, an estate agent in Australia is being prosecuted for alleged ‘under quoting’.

This is how the Australians term a practice by which properties are advertised for sale at a lower guide price than the agent’s own valuation.

‘Under quoting’, used as bait to drum up interest and tempt purchasers to participate in open days and auctions, is said to be common in Australia where sales by bidding are routine.

The practice means that would-be buyers can waste money on fees when they could never actually afford to buy the property.

Others do buy but end up paying more than they had been led to believe would be the case.

However, ‘under quoting’ is said to be notoriously difficult to prove and this would be the first prosecution in more than a decade.

The agency, Bresic Whitney in Sydney, is accused of ‘under quoting’ on two properties.

One was marketed with a price guide of $1.5m, when the agency agreement with the vendor had a low end value of $1.6m. The property sold for $1.76m.

‘Under quoting’ is specifically illegal in Australia under the Property, Stock and Business Agents Act 2002, with penalties of up to $22,000 and, importantly, cancellation of the estate agent’s licence.

Trading Standards (or their Australian equivalent) has apparently been attending auction sales and open days incognito, and examining sales agreements.

With many auction houses in the UK never failing to crow in their post-sale publicity about how certain properties went for prices miles above their guides, one can’t help wondering whether there might be a test here – perhaps under Consumer Protection Regulations?


Email the story to a friend

One Comment

  1. fluter

    So an agent set the guide price of the property at 6.25% below his low valuation and achieved 9.1% above this figure, how dreadful! Surly he should do as many do over here and market the property at well above realistic expectations (easy way to get an instruction), fail to sell it as happens in most cases, reduce the price and eventually, many months later, sell for less than a more realistic agent may have recommended in the first place. Simple fact, create fair competition amongst buyers to achieve the best result for your client!


You must be logged in to report this comment!

Leave a reply

If you want to create a user account so you can log in, click here

More top news stories

Thank you for signing up to our newsletter, we have sent you an email asking you to confirm your subscription. Additionally if you would like to create a free EYE account which allows you to comment on news stories and manage your email subscriptions please enter a password below.