Every year, I review the annual accounts of the UK’s largest estate agencies to see how the market is faring and it has revealed a very interesting picture, with some of the upmarket estate agencies retaining a high level of profitability while some of the internet hybrids continue to lose millions of pounds each year.
If ever there was proof that you should charge what you’re worth and not join the race to the bottom, it is there in black and white, at Companies House, for all to see.
Some agents are still to file accounts for 2019, no doubt taking advantage of the government’s three-month extension for filing accounts because of Covid. All eyes will be on the results posted by Leaders Romans, Connells, Kinleigh Folkard & Hayward (KFH), Chestertons and Yopa.
During the two-year period of 2017-18, Leaders Romans showed a loss of £50m and, at the end of 2018, were carrying heavy debts of £256m.
Connells’ profits had been in cut in half from £84m in 2017 to £45m a year later; KFH managed to pop £4.9m in the bank over the two years, Chestertons showed a good leap from £173k profit to £1.5m, while Yopa lost £48.7m over that same period. How much more can the embattled shareholders of Yopa take?
For those that have already filed this year, we see an interesting picture emerging, particularly if we look at the online hybrids. Purplebricks has lost a total of £74m in the two years since May 2018 on the back of a £31m loss the previous year – that’s over £100m in just a three-year period. Meanwhile, Strike (formerly Housesimple) lost £25m over the two-year period from April 2017, on the back of a £10m loss the previous year.
How long can Purplebricks and Strike keep persuading investors and shareholders to part with their cash while continuing to lose so much money? Their models have yet to prove they are viable over the long term.
Foxtons also had a bad two-year run, losing £25m during 2018 – 2019 – compared to a £5.3m profit in 2017. It raised an extra £22m from shareholders shortly after the start of the pandemic to ensure liquidity and in a worse case trading scenario due to Covid.
Countrywide had the largest positive swing, clawing their losses back from £218m in 2018, to £42m in 2019.
LSL, which backed out of Countrywide merger talks in March this year, has seen profits drop, from £33.4m in 2017, to £17.8m in 2018 and more recently £12.9m in 2019.
Those remaining stable include Savills, whose UK division has, in the years 2017 – 2019, contributed £40m-£50m profit a year to the PLC result, which in 2019 was a profit of £83.6m,up £6.4m on 2018. Although its balance sheets remain strong, its debts have increased. Its UK division is also showing an £8.9m pension deficit, compared to a £2.7m surplus in 2018.
Others who are also showing a consistent increase in profit include Carter Jonas, who banked £10-£12m profit a year in 2017-19, the Belvoir Property Group rising from £3m to £4.6m over the same period and Winkworth from £1.1m to £1.3m over the same period.
Over at the Acorn Group, CEO Rob Sargent – the figurehead of the Say No to Rightmove campaign – has done a great job with his team getting the group’s profits up to £2m a year.
Douglas and Gordon turned a corner in 2018/19, coming into the black at £78k, after losing £1.4m over the previous two years.
Profits have slipped for Arun from £11.5m in 2017 to £7.3m in 2019 and Chancellors (Group) from £1.7m to £642k. At Dexters, profit in 2018/19 was £3.6m, down £1m from the previous year.
I’m not sure what’s happening over at Andrews & Partners. It swung from a £3.8m profit in 2018 to a £1m loss in 2019. Beresfords has also taken a hit from £312k profit in 2017/8 to a £229k loss a year later.
It will be interesting to see what this year’s roller coaster will do to the next sets of accounts! With such a mixed picture, it highlights how important it is for us to talk up the industry right now and not fall into a Covid-led slump during the year ahead.
Paul Smith is chief executive officer of Spicerhaart.
Some of these businesses have never made a single penny of profit. Can they really be described as businesses? There will be lots of other opportunities for investors next year, in other sectors, due to the economic climate, and I can’t imagine investors will continue to chase their losses in firms that are on life support.
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register
Why is property eye allowing this person to talk about all his competitors in a negative way without divulging his own accounts?
Whilst some of these companies have either had a cut in profits or turned a loss many didn’t cut hundreds of hard working staff at the worst possible time via a conference call early this year, unlike spicerhaart.
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register
They are no secret. https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/04430726/filing-history
Loss of £2.7m in 2018. Loss of £2.6m in 2019.
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register
Confirmation there are huge losses. They are certainly closing branches, but trying hard to wrap it up with the positive vibe of opening Hubs. Not yet quite recovered for the shabby way they dealt with their own staff prior to lockdown, you would think some of these new HUB recruits would think twice, with a potentially more difficult market looming post March 21.
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register
Interestingly Paul did not mention his own Company’s performance on the last accounts, which are fully available at Companies House. People in glass houses…….
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register
No surprise that he reserved his kind words for those like KFH, Chestertons, Acorn and D&G – who were his chums in the failed OTM venture. In keeping his vitriol for his disliked competitors Connells, PB,Yopa, Strike etc he seems to have missed that Connells profits were probably still better than most of the next biggest 10 firms added together.
PIE should be embarrassed to let a vested interest tout his wares like this, bigging-up his homies, badmouthing his enemies and not even mentioning his own loss making / branch closing company.
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register