With few exceptions, property companies seem unable or unwilling to make their businesses work in countries other than the one in which they were founded.
Why does Rightmove stick rigidly to the UK? After all, it is a commercial giant here and the darling of the stock market and you’d imagine that it would be tempting to replicate that performance in Europe or the US.
Talking of which, why has Zillow stayed confined solely to the US? The super-successful portal dominates the American property space there and now has a value of over $12 billion. Why not make a smart move into the UK which, after all, is one of the most lucrative markets on the planet? It would increase its shareholder value still further, wouldn’t it?
Foxtons monumentally failed in the USA. And, famously, Purplebricks’ expansion into Australia, Germany, Canada and the United States was a huge flop and ultimately the reason that Michael Bruce left the business.
Yes, there are a couple of big brands that have a presence overseas such as Savills and Knight Frank but even they utilise partner agents in many territories. Importantly, both of these firms are better known abroad for their consultancy and commercial work rather than as estate agency brands per se.
Here in Britain, we’ve not seen the likes of Keller Williams nor eXp hit big numbers. These American styled ‘real estate’ businesses count just 700 or so agents between them, just 1% or so of the country’s total despite launching here years ago.
So why? Why do overseas brands not perform well in the UK and vice versa?
I think the answer to this is simply because each entity believes that it can impose its domestic business model on additional countries. This is a mistake.
There are of course certain markets that are similar to each other. For instance, France, Italy, Spain and Portugal operate in a similar way to each other as does the USA and Canada. But, the US vs the UK, the US versus Europe, the UK vs Europe… there are differences.
Maybe, just perhaps, it’s us that are the odd one. After all, domestically we charge some of the lowest fees in the world. We have one of the most draconian, slow and uncertain conveyancing processes and we do not have a licensing regime.
Therefore, to try to shoehorn a model that works brilliantly in Florida to Hull, isn’t going to work out too well and this is what some of the early US self-employed businesses have found here whilst insisting upon labelling us Brits as ‘realtors’ that ‘close sales’ in the ‘real estate’ market. The terminology does not always fit.
But apart from foreign terminology in many senses of the word, British estate agents are used to a different set of legal rules too, a unique business culture and, yes, those low fees to contend with and scant room for ‘buy side agents’ and ‘broker splits’ etc.
There’s plenty of opportunity for overseas property companies to expand cross-territory. But they need to have both an understanding of and a respect for the new markets in which they are launching. Not all countries are the same just as not all estate agencies are the same.
Can an international estate agency company flourish here? I’ll let you know.
Lee O’Brien is UK managing director of iad, the international estate agency business which recently launched in the UK.
Global estate agency opens in the UK after completing acquisition
Australia may have 1/3 of the size of the UK population, but it operates on a lucrative 2.5 – 3% commission rate. Surely worth consideration for some?
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register
Funny! Have you ever tried competing with an Ozzie?
The same spirit that whoops GB from here to kingdom come on the sports-field is present in everything they do. Go there to holiday but not to compete with them.
We’re too superior, too confident, too lazy and too quick to whinge
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register
We are better than them at football.
Athletics.
Cycling.
Boxing.
When was the last time they won the rugby world cup?
Tour de France?
Football world cup?
They beat us at cricket usually and rugby league usually.
I have a good mate in Aussie have bene many times. They are far more laid back about work then we are.
My buddy who sold his business (Frontline ) for 30m said he was amazed at how hard we work here when he came over as he did regularly.
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register
Wow wow wow, did you say rugby league?
Australia are scared to death of us. They refused to play GB a few years ago, and have consistently avoided playing England since we played them in the 2017 World Cup Final, making all sorts of excuses.
Even the enemy, St Helens, won the World Club Challenge this year against “The Best Team In The World(TM)”
The above is said in good spirits of course, and you’re absolutely right about Aussies – their competitive spirit is formidable.
Back on the subject though – the UK is not an attractive market when all is said and done. Our fees are too low, and our reputation is **** because of it. If you look at the USA and Aussie models, their professionalism far outstrips ours on average, and estate agents are looked up to as professionals.
I’m no expert, but my observation is that the US and Australia are regulated, and dominated by fewer, larger firms, and to be part of those firms, you have to operate by their stringent rules. The UK market is, horribly fragmented by comparison, and dominated by tiny, stressed, businesses with no-one to turn to, and who have a hard enough time keeping the lights on.
So the foreign models think we’re not worth bothering with, and the British models are undercooked compared to their indigenous competitors. I think that pretty much sums it up.
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register
Have confidence! Having been here for 6 years, it’s amazing the difference a Brit can make!
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register
Simple answer ….. all countries developed their own outlook on life and attitudes. None of which rarely agree on doing things the same way, real estate is no different. The French are the worst very quickly followed by USA.
You must be logged in to like or dislike this comments.
Click to login
Don't have an account? Click here to register