Letting agent which did not show its fees loses appeal against £5,000 fine

A letting agency which was fined after not showing its fees has had its appeal against the maximum £5,000 fine rejected by a judge.

Hamlet Homes was fined by Reading Borough Council after breaching the Consumer Rights Act 2015. The council has previously said that nine in ten agents in the town do not comply.

The Act requires agents to advertise their fees, to state whether or not they are a member of a Client Money Protection scheme and give details of the redress scheme they belong to.

The firm, in Oxford Road, Reading, was visited by the council’s Private Sector Housing Team in January and given until April to rectify the situation, but did not do so.

As a result, the firm was issued with a notice of intent, which resulted in the £5,000 fine.

At the appeal, the company director Gurprit Singh Johal and company secretary Kamalpreet Johal argued they were not adequately informed it was a legal requirement or what the timescale was.

They also claimed the fine was excessive.

But Judge Brian Kennedy QC ruled he was satisfied the business had failed to comply with the law and dismissed the appeal.

Reading Borough Council warned in March this year that almost 90% of agents in the town were not publishing their fees and warned it would go after them.

Cllr Richard Davies, Reading’s lead member for housing, said: “The council’s Private Sector Housing Team are working hard to enforce the new regulations in the Consumer Rights Act and are getting results.

“Most agents who are visited comply with the law within an agreed period if they are not already. Unfortunately, in this one case the agents failed to take action despite repeated warnings and visits.

“I hope the outcome of this case demonstrates that the council will do everything in its powers to ensure all letting agents abide by these regulations which are there to protect tenants and landlords.”

x

Email the story to a friend!



6 Comments

  1. moneymanager16

    Question.

    Does this apply to a landlord who lets and manages direct?

    Report
    1. jeremy1960

      Yes. Tenants must be made aware of all costs that they may incur before during and after a tenancy, why would you think landlords are above the law? That said, most of the agents in our town believe themselves above the law and trading standards appear to agree by ignoring tip offs and doing nothing about enforcement!

      Report
  2. Mark Walker

    Well done Reading Borough Council.

    Report
  3. Ding Dong

    Great to see a prosecution, and hopefully many more will follow, but how stupid must you be to get a “notice of intent” and still NOT comply.

    This agency should be struck off full stop for incompetence.  Personally, would like to see prosecutions without notice considering the law to advertise fees has been in over a year.

    Report
  4. Woodentop

    And about time. I am surprised they even attempted to appeal based on the content of the story …. they were warned before to get their act together! Ignorance is not a defence in law and for a barrister to put the appeal forward says a lot! If you run any business it is your responsibility to keep pace with regulations & legislation.

    Report
  5. femaleagent88

    “At the appeal, the company director Gurprit Singh Johal and company secretary Kamalpreet Johal argued they were not adequately informed it was a legal requirement or what the timescale was”

    It’s your duty to know the law, how you can run a sucessful trustyworthy compliant business and not know something that has been a hot topic and more to the point gives you opportunity to easily know what your competitors are doing…

    Report
X

You must be logged in to report this comment!

Comments are closed.

Thank you for signing up to our newsletter, we have sent you an email asking you to confirm your subscription. Additionally if you would like to create a free EYE account which allows you to comment on news stories and manage your email subscriptions please enter a password below.